John Foster’s original song “Tell That Angel I Love Her” was a deeply emotional tribute to his late friend, Maggie Dunn, who tragically passed away in a car accident in 2022. The performance showcased Foster’s heartfelt lyrics and soulful delivery, capturing the pain and love he felt for his friend. His rendition moved both the audience and the judges, earning him a spot in the Top 20 of American Idol Season 23.
The song’s poignant lyrics express a longing to communicate with the departed, with lines like “Lord, won’t you tell that angel I love her?” Foster’s performance was accompanied by his acoustic guitar, adding to the intimate and personal nature of the tribute. The judges praised his authenticity and storytelling ability, with Carrie Underwood likening him to her own son and expressing pride in his progress on the show.
“Tell That Angel I Love Her” was featured during the Top 20 performances of American Idol Season 23, which aired on April 20, 2025. The episode had a “Songs of Faith” theme, and Foster’s heartfelt tribute stood out among the performances.
The song’s emotional depth and Foster’s sincere delivery resonated with viewers, contributing to his advancement in the competition. His journey on American Idol has been marked by personal tributes and authentic performances, earning him a dedicated fanbase and critical acclaim.
Foster’s performance of “Tell That Angel I Love Her” remains a testament to his ability to convey deep emotions through music, and it continues to be a highlight of his American Idol journey.