During the second night of Disney-themed performances, Jamal Roberts, a 27-year-old gym teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, delivered a soulful rendition of “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” from the Disney film Remember the Titans. His performance was met with a standing ovation from judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. However, judge Carrie Underwood remained seated and critiqued his lack of stage movement, urging him to give a more dynamic performance. Many viewers felt her critique was unfair, especially given that other contestants also had stationary performances without similar feedback. Fans voiced their dissatisfaction on social media, accusing Carrie of bias and rudeness, with some demanding her replacement .
Prior to this performance, Jamal had impressed both the judges and audience with his heartfelt tributes to his mother and his powerful renditions of songs from Disney films. His consistent emotional connection and vocal strength had earned him a spot in the Top 3 of the competition. Despite the criticism from Carrie Underwood, Jamal’s performance on Disney Night solidified his place as a fan favorite and a strong contender in the finale .
The Top 3 finalistsโJamal Roberts, John Foster, and Breanna Nixโadvanced to the season finale, where they would compete for the title of American Idol. The finale featured performances by various musical guests, including Brandon Lake, Goo Goo Dolls, Jessica Simpson, and Patti LaBelle, among others. Judges Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Carrie Underwood also performed together, and Jelly Roll, the artist in residence, took the stage
Jamal’s journey on American Idol showcased his growth as an artist and his ability to connect with audiences through his powerful performances. His rendition of “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” exemplified his vocal prowess and emotional depth, leaving a lasting impression on both the judges and viewers alike.
As the competition neared its end, Jamal Roberts stood out not only for his talent but also for his resilience in the face of criticism. His performance on Disney Night was a testament to his dedication and passion for music, making him a memorable contestant in American Idol Season 23.