John Foster, an 18-year-old country singer from Addis, Louisiana, delivered a heartfelt rendition of Randy Travis’s “I Told You So” during the Top 12 episode of American Idol 2025. Inspired by Carrie Underwood’s version of the song, Foster chose to perform it directly to her, aiming to connect emotionally with both the judges and the audience.
The performance was part of a special episode where contestants honored iconic “American Idol” moments. Foster’s choice to sing “I Told You So” was a tribute to Underwood’s influence on his musical journey. His delivery was marked by sincerity and emotional depth, capturing the essence of the song’s themes of regret and longing
Judges Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie expressed admiration for Foster’s growth and authenticity. Underwood, in particular, likened him to her oldest son and praised his progress throughout the competition. Bryan and Richie commended his storytelling ability and vocal control, affirming his place in the competition.
Foster’s performance of “I Told You So” solidified his position in the Top 10, showcasing his ability to convey deep emotion and connect with his audience. His journey on American Idol continues to inspire, demonstrating the power of music to bridge personal experiences and shared sentiments.